# Cairn Review - An Uphill Battle Worth Taking On

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubafbH5JZ2Y
Recap page: https://rapidrecap.app/video/ubafbH5JZ2Y
Generated: 2026-01-29T14:49:01.187+00:00

---
## Quick Overview

The game Karen, a climbing and survival experience, succeeds by focusing intensely on deliberate, inelegant, and realistic climbing mechanics that force the player to internalize form and technique through constant failure, ultimately forging a deep, shared sense of accomplishment with the player character, Ava, during the 12-hour ascent of Mount Kami.

**Key Points:**
- Climbing in Karen is intentionally not 'awesome,' 'sexy,' or 'smooth'; it is described as 'inelgant and at times harsh' but 'honest' like a real-life skill, requiring individual limb placement by the player.
- The game minimizes user interface elements for climbing, forcing players to rely on reading Ava's body language—such as buckling arms and knees—to discern hold quality and fatigue.
- The reviewer experienced constant failure, burning through resources over a 12-hour trek up Mount Kami, which 'humbled me' and forced a reevaluation of destructive choices and routing.
- Survival mechanics involve scavenging resources like water, food, and materials from the wild or the corpses of fallen climbers, with crafting recipes like the 'grit' status effect improving long-term stamina.
- Ava's motivation for climbing is rooted in personal discontent, as evidenced by calls from a partner stressing home issues and a manager trying to control the 'renowned athlete,' suggesting she seeks clarity away from life's pressures.
- The experience becomes a 'two-hander' between the player and Ava, culminating in a feeling that reaching the peak was about aiding Ava through her 'lengthy full body death-deying exorcism' rather than just achieving a game goal.

**Context:** The transcript reviews 'Karen,' a climbing and survival game developed by Bakers, focusing on the arduous journey of the protagonist, Ava, up Mount Kami. The game presents players with constant micro-decisions regarding resource management (gear vs. food) and precise climbing technique, emphasizing realism and the inevitability of failure as core components of the experience.

## Detailed Analysis

Karen delivers a challenging experience by drilling down on core mechanics, particularly its deliberate and realistic climbing system where players individually control Ava's hand and foot placement, often resulting in disastrous technique until honed through repetition. The game strips away typical video game smoothness, instead demanding players internalize good form, which is tested by narrow slits in rock formations and long climbs requiring pace control. Survival elements are interwoven, requiring players to manage inventory space for scavenged items like food and materials, while utilizing tools like hand tape and chalk; the 'grit' status effect proved especially useful for lengthy ascents. Failure is central, evidenced by Ava's vocalized screams upon falling and visual cues like screen blurring from cold or hunger, yet these constant setbacks force the player to become a better climber, matching Ava's established expertise. Furthermore, the narrative explores Ava's internal motivations for fleeing to Mount Kami, hinted at through strained external communications from a partner and manager, suggesting she seeks existential clarity on the mountain, a journey the player ultimately supports by ensuring she reaches the peak, fostering a deep, shared emotional connection between player and character.

### Climbing Mechanics Analysis

- Climbing is inelegant and harsh, requiring individual limb placement by the player
- Ava automatically selects which limb advances, but placement angles are player-controlled
- Success requires internalizing good form, which contrasts sharply with initial haphazard technique.

### Survival and Resource Management

- Players must choose between scavenging climbing gear or raw materials for meals at abandoned camps
- Resources like water, noodles, and herbs fill Ava's limited pack space
- The 'grit' status effect freezes survival meters, useful during trying climbs.

### User Interface and Feedback

- Karen largely lacks UI elements for climbing, forcing reliance on Ava's body language to gauge hold quality and fatigue
- Failure is expected, leading to audible cries and visual blurring when Ava succumbs to elements or exhaustion.

### Narrative and Character Motivation

- Ava flees to Mount Kami because 'life just makes more sense with her head in the clouds' and a sheer cliff to climb
- Encounters with others, like calls from a partner, highlight unresolved issues at home
- The player's goal shifts to helping Ava overcome her personal 'exorcism' rather than just summiting.

### Player Experience and Accomplishment

- Constant failure humbled the reviewer over the 12-hour track up Mount Kami, forcing reorientation of approach
- Overcoming risky climbs results in surprising feelings of accomplishment through honed technique
- The experience transcends typical gaming, becoming a shared terror and eventual clarity achieved with Ava.