# الكلاسيكو - فقرة اختيار الأفضل مع الكابتن أيمن منصور.. عواد ولا الشناوي؟.. والكرتي ولا إمام؟

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDf9Xa-YMMs
Recap page: https://rapidrecap.app/video/pDf9Xa-YMMs
Generated: 2025-07-21T20:06:31.299+00:00

---
## Quick Overview

Former Zamalek player Ayman Mansour chose Al Ahly's Mohamed El Shenawy over Zamalek's Mohamed Awad as the better goalkeeper, citing El Shenawy's current achievements. He also picked Zamalek's Omar Gaber over Al Ahly's Mohamed Hany, and Zamalek's Hossam Abdelmaguid over Al Ahly's Yasser Ibrahim, advising Abdelmaguid to prioritize Zamalek's fans and entity if he considers moving to Al Ahly. Mansour ultimately selected Pyramids FC's Walid El Karti over Al Ahly's Emam Ashour, emphasizing professionalism in transfers.

**Key Points:**
- Former Zamalek player Ayman Mansour selected Al Ahly's Mohamed El Shenawy as the superior goalkeeper over Zamalek's Mohamed Awad, based on current performance and titles.
- Mansour chose Zamalek's Omar Gaber over Al Ahly's Mohamed Hany for the right-back position.
- He preferred Zamalek's Hossam Abdelmaguid over Al Ahly's Yasser Ibrahim as a central defender, noting Abdelmaguid's advanced stage of development.
- Mansour advised Hossam Abdelmaguid to prioritize Zamalek's fans and entity if he considers a move to Al Ahly, drawing on his own experience of choosing Zamalek over Al Ahly.
- He selected Pyramids FC's Walid El Karti as a better player than Al Ahly's Emam Ashour.
- Mansour emphasized that player transfers are a matter of professionalism, supply, and demand, criticizing the over-dramatization of such moves in Egyptian football.

![Screenshot at 0:14: Host and guest in a studio with a large screen displaying photos of goalkeepers Mohamed Awad and Mohamed El Shenawy for comparison](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-00-14.png)

**Context:** In a segment of the "El Classico" show, former Zamalek player and Egyptian national team member Ayman Mansour participated in a rapid-fire comparison of current players from rival Egyptian clubs, Al Ahly and Zamalek, along with a player from Pyramids FC. The host challenged Mansour to choose between pairs of players, prompting him to offer insights into his selections and broader views on player loyalty and professionalism in football.

## Detailed Analysis

During the "El Classico" show, former Zamalek player Ayman Mansour engaged in a series of direct player comparisons between Al Ahly and Zamalek, and one player from Pyramids FC. When asked to choose between goalkeepers Mohamed Awad (Zamalek) and Mohamed El Shenawy (Al Ahly), Mansour unequivocally picked El Shenawy, stating that while Awad has potential, El Shenawy's current achievements and experience in major matches make him superior. For the right-back position, Mansour selected Omar Gaber (Zamalek) over Mohamed Hany (Al Ahly). In the central defense comparison between Yasser Ibrahim (Al Ahly) and Hossam Abdelmaguid (Zamalek), Mansour chose Abdelmaguid, acknowledging his advanced development. When confronted with a hypothetical scenario about Abdelmaguid wanting to join Al Ahly, Mansour advised him to prioritize Zamalek's fans and entity, recounting his own past decision to stay with Zamalek despite an offer from Al Ahly. He stressed that player transfers are a professional matter of supply and demand, likening it to global football where stars like Messi and Ronaldo move clubs without excessive drama. Finally, when asked to compare Walid El Karti (Pyramids FC) and Emam Ashour (Al Ahly), Mansour chose El Karti, praising his quality as a player. He reiterated his belief that players should be direct about their intentions to move, emphasizing transparency in professional football.

### Goalkeeper Comparison

- Ayman Mansour chose Mohamed El Shenawy over Mohamed Awad
- El Shenawy's current achievements and experience were cited as reasons for his superiority
- Mansour noted Awad's potential but highlighted El Shenawy's proven track record

### Right-Back Comparison

- Mansour selected Omar Gaber over Mohamed Hany
- He did not provide detailed reasoning for this specific choice

### Center-Back Comparison

- Hossam Abdelmaguid was chosen over Yasser Ibrahim
- Mansour stated Abdelmaguid is "ahead in stages" despite Yasser's progress

### Player Loyalty and Transfers

- Mansour advised Hossam Abdelmaguid to prioritize Zamalek's fans and entity if considering a move to Al Ahly
- He shared his personal experience of choosing Zamalek over Al Ahly despite an offer
- Mansour emphasized that player transfers are a professional matter of "supply and demand"
- He criticized the over-dramatization of player transfers in Egyptian football, citing global examples like Messi and Ronaldo

### Midfielder Comparison

- Walid El Karti was chosen over Emam Ashour
- Mansour praised El Karti as a "great player"
- He reiterated that player decisions are personal and professional, not a cause for anger or drama

![Screenshot at 0:00: Ayman Mansour, the guest, sitting at the studio desk](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-00-00.png)
![Screenshot at 0:02: Female host pointing towards the large screen in the studio](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-00-02.png)
![Screenshot at 0:12: Wide shot of the studio with the host and guest, and a screen showing goalkeepers Mohamed Awad and Mohamed El Shenawy](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-00-12.png)
![Screenshot at 0:45: Screen displaying photos of Omar Gaber and Mohamed Hany for comparison](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-00-45.png)
![Screenshot at 1:08: Screen showing photos of Yasser Ibrahim and Hossam Abdelmaguid for comparison](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-01-08.png)
![Screenshot at 1:54: On-screen graphic identifying the guest as Ayman Mansour, former Zamalek player and Egyptian national team member](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-01-54.png)
![Screenshot at 2:17: Screen displaying photos of Walid El Karti and Emam Ashour for comparison](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-02-17.png)
![Screenshot at 3:26: Host holding a "El Classico" branded card](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/pDf9Xa-YMMs/00-03-26.png)