# Entre risos e sussurros | Ana Clara Yoshioka de Godoi | TEDxColégio Medianeira Youth Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p2kRXuVNfcQ Recap page: https://rapidrecap.app/video/p2kRXuVNfcQ Generated: 2025-11-11T00:37:20.589+00:00 --- ## Quick Overview Ana Clara Yoshioka de Godoi discusses how the mimetic desire theory, derived from René Girard, explains the roots of female rivalry and silent bullying, asserting that women often desire what other women desire, leading to conflict, and offers actionable advice like not reacting emotionally or pointing fingers to combat this relational aggression. **Key Points:** - The speaker explores female rivalry and silent bullying, attributing them to mimetic desire, where individuals desire what others desire. - Mimetic desire, based on René Girard's theory, explains that people often desire things because others desire them, leading to conflict over scarce resources or status. - The speaker recounts a personal anecdote involving three friends (Isa, Mariana, and Laura) where one friend's desire for a pink water bottle, modeled after a celebrity, caused friction. - Relational aggression, or social bullying, is defined as non-physical aggression designed to harm a person's social standing, often through manipulative behaviors. - Practical advice for combating this aggression includes not reacting emotionally, avoiding blame, and seeking support within larger social circles rather than isolating oneself. - The speaker contrasts the perceived modern fragility of relationships (like divorce rates) with historical relationships, suggesting that modern social dynamics exacerbate these rivalries. ![Screenshot at 00:17: Speaker Ana Clara Yoshioka de Godoi on stage holding up a bracelet as an example of an object that can cause social conflict due to desire.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-00-17.png) **Context:** This TEDx talk, presented by Ana Clara Yoshioka de Godoi at TEDxColégio Medianeira Youth, addresses the complex dynamics of female rivalry and relational aggression, often termed 'silent bullying.' The speaker uses philosophical concepts, specifically René Girard's theory of mimetic desire, to frame why women often compete over the same objects, social statuses, or even romantic partners, and explores the emotional impact this has, particularly on younger women. ## Detailed Analysis Ana Clara Yoshioka de Godoi delivers a talk on 'Entre Risos e Sussurros' (Between Laughs and Whispers), focusing on female rivalry and silent bullying, which she connects to René Girard's concept of Mimetic Desire. She explains that mimetic desire posits that humans do not know what they truly desire but rather imitate the desires of others, leading to rivalry when multiple people desire the same scarce object or status. She illustrates this with an anecdote about friends desiring a specific pink water bottle associated with a celebrity, leading to conflict and isolation for the victim. The speaker defines relational aggression as non-physical bullying aimed at damaging social position through manipulative behaviors. She highlights that this phenomenon occurs across various settings, from schools to the workplace. To combat this, she suggests practical strategies: avoiding emotional reactions, refraining from blaming, and seeking support in broader social groups instead of isolating oneself. She contrasts the fragility of modern relationships (citing high divorce rates) with stronger historical bonds, emphasizing that the current social environment, characterized by perceived scarcity of desirable attributes (beauty, status, wealth), intensifies these rivalries, making it harder for victims to confront the aggressors directly. ### Introduction to Relational Aggression - Speaker introduces the topic of female rivalry and silent bullying (bullying silencioso) using an example of a friendship bracelet (00:17). - The speaker details how relational aggression is non-physical and aims to damage social standing (02:23). - The core issue is that women often desire what other women desire, leading to conflict (02:59). ### Theoretical Framework - Mimetic Desire: Speaker introduces René Girard's concept of Mimetic Desire, where people imitate others' desires, leading to rivalry (04:50). - Girard's quote is displayed: 'Man is the creature who does not know what to desire and resorts to others to decide. We desire what others desire because we imitate their desires.' (05:04). - This desire for what others want makes relationships more fragile in the modern era (07:34). ### Practical Implications and Solutions - The speaker illustrates the mimetic dynamic with an example of friends desiring a specific pink water bottle associated with a celebrity (05:51). - It is harder to confront relational aggression than direct aggression because the victim often feels isolated or blamed (08:55). - Solutions include not reacting emotionally, not pointing fingers, and seeking support in larger social circles instead of isolating oneself (08:58). ![Screenshot at 00:01: The opening graphic displaying the event name: TEDx Colégio Medianeira Youth.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-00-01.png) ![Screenshot at 00:10: Wide shot of the stage setup featuring the speaker walking onto the stage marked by a large pink circle.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-00-10.png) ![Screenshot at 00:17: Speaker Ana Clara holding up a bracelet, using it as a tangible example of an object that can provoke desire and rivalry.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-00-17.png) ![Screenshot at 00:28: The initial slide on the screen showing the talk title: '13 - ENTRE RISOS E SUSSURROS: DESVENDANDO A RIVALIDADE FEMININA E O BULLYING SILENCIOSO!'](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-00-28.png) ![Screenshot at 01:17: The speaker gesturing while discussing how female friendships are often strained by rivalry and competition.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-01-17.png) ![Screenshot at 03:44: A slide appears featuring René Girard, the philosopher whose theories the speaker uses to frame the discussion on desire.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-03-44.png) ![Screenshot at 05:04: A slide displaying Girard's quote on mimetic desire: 'O homem é a criatura que não sabe o que desejar e recorre aos outros para se decidir. Desejamos o que os outros desejam porque imitamos os seus desejos.'](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-05-04.png) ![Screenshot at 07:26: A slide changes to show the concept of 'Vida Líquida' \(Liquid Life\) related to sociologist Zygmunt Bauman.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-07-26.png) ![Screenshot at 09:07: The final slide appears with the word 'Obrigada' \(Thank You\) as the speaker concludes her presentation.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/p2kRXuVNfcQ/00-09-07.png)