# Peacemaker S2 Episode 3 - IS THIS EARTH-X?! - Angry Review

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asUE9wg3uDc
Recap page: https://rapidrecap.app/video/asUE9wg3uDc
Generated: 2025-09-09T01:06:11.196+00:00

---
## Quick Overview

The review of Peacemaker Season 2 Episode 3 concludes that the episode significantly improves upon previous installments by venturing into an alternate dimension where Peacemaker finds himself celebrated, while also revealing crucial backstory about Harcourt's past with Rick Flag Jr. that explains her coldness towards him. The episode is praised for its brutal action, character development, and intriguing setup, though the true nature of the seemingly utopian alternate universe remains a central mystery, with theories ranging from a fascist regime to Earth-X.

**Key Points:**
- Episode 3 successfully transports viewers to an alternate dimension where Peacemaker is beloved and respected, a stark contrast to his usual reception.
- A significant flashback reveals Harcourt's past relationship with Rick Flag Jr., including a "friends with benefits" dynamic, and his subsequent death at Peacemaker's hands, providing context for her animosity.
- The episode features a "hilariously brutal and creative" action sequence where Peacemaker, without his suit, confronts the Sons of Liberty.
- Rick Flag Jr. is alive and well in this alternate universe, depicted as "very dorky" and engaging in fun action sequences.
- The seemingly perfect alternate universe raises suspicions, with "smiles and sunshine and rainbows perhaps a little too much," leading to speculation about its true, potentially oppressive nature, possibly fascist or Earth-X.
- The review highlights Tim Meadows' continued comedic contributions and Eagley's "badass action sequence," but ultimately favors this episode over episode two.
- The episode ends on a cliffhanger with Argus assembling an elite team to hunt Eagley, while Judomaster is teased for a return, setting up future conflicts.

**Context:** This review covers "Peacemaker Season 2 Episode 3 - IS THIS EARTH-X?!" and discusses the DCU's recent announcements, including the "Man of Tomorrow" film. The episode itself focuses heavily on Peacemaker (Chris Smith) traveling to an alternate dimension, a significant plot development after the events of Season 1. The review also delves into the character dynamics, particularly the relationship between Harcourt and Rick Flag Jr., and speculates on the nature of the alternate universe, drawing comparisons to comic book lore like Earth-X.

## Detailed Analysis

This review of "Peacemaker Season 2 Episode 3" praises the episode for its strong narrative progression and character development, deeming it superior to episode two. The core of the episode involves Peacemaker entering an alternate dimension where he is a celebrated hero, a stark contrast to his usual experiences. This alternate universe is depicted as idyllic, but the reviewers express skepticism, suspecting an underlying darkness, possibly a fascist regime or mirroring Earth-X from the comics where Nazis won. Crucial backstory is revealed through a flashback, showing Harcourt's past intimacy with Rick Flag Jr. and his subsequent death by Peacemaker, which retrospectively explains Harcourt's harsh treatment of Chris. The episode includes a notable action sequence where a suit-less Peacemaker engages the Sons of Liberty with brutal creativity, and features a surprisingly alive and "dorky" Rick Flag Jr. in the alternate dimension. The humor, particularly from Tim Meadows, is noted as effective, and Eagley has a "badass action sequence." However, the review also points out potential narrative stretches, like Harcourt's continued animosity despite the circumstances, and critiques the rehashed exposition from earlier episodes. The episode concludes with a cliffhanger involving Argus targeting Eagley and a tease of Judomaster's return, setting the stage for future conflicts and the eventual reveal of the alternate universe's true nature, with Lex Luthor speculated as a potential cameo.

### Episode Plot Progression

- Peacemaker travels to an alternate dimension where he is celebrated
- Harcourt's past with Rick Flag Jr. is revealed, explaining her animosity towards Peacemaker
- An action sequence involves a suit-less Peacemaker fighting the Sons of Liberty
- Rick Flag Jr. appears alive and well in the alternate dimension
- The episode concludes with Argus targeting Eagley and a tease of Judomaster's return

### Alternate Universe Speculation

- The alternate dimension is presented as utopian but suspected to be fascist or Earth-X
- Theories suggest Nazis won a war, leading to a structured fascist society
- Subtle hints like "14 stars" and the absence of minorities fuel speculation
- The presence of Autobio, who wouldn't exist in such a regime, creates a narrative conflict
- The possibility of the universe being genuinely good, forcing Peacemaker to choose to leave, is considered a harder narrative path

### Character Development & Backstory

- Harcourt's relationship with Rick Flag Jr. is revealed as more complex than previously known
- Peacemaker's past actions, including killing Rick Flag Jr., are directly linked to Harcourt's behavior
- The contrast between the alternate universe's reception of Peacemaker and his usual reception is highlighted
- Tim Meadows' performance and humor are consistently praised
- Vigilante's character is critiqued for repetitive "spider facts" jokes, with a desire for more substantial material

### Action and Humor

- Peacemaker's "hilariously brutal and creative" solo action sequence is a highlight
- Eagley has a "badass action sequence"
- Rick Flag Jr.'s "dorky" antics provide comedic relief during action
- Tim Meadows delivers effective and "rude" jokes
- The episode is considered better than episode two, which was called a "filler episode"

### Reviewer Verdict and Future Predictions

- The episode is rated favorably, with reviewers giving it a 7 or 8 out of 10
- The episode is seen as a significant improvement over episode two
- Future predictions include a confrontation between Eagley/Peacemaker and Argus
- Lex Luthor is speculated as a potential cameo, possibly due to his knowledge of alternate dimensions
- The remaining episodes, especially those written and directed by James Gunn, are highly anticipated for major cameos and plot resolutions