Two of Them? That’s a Bit Too Much | Am I The A**hole? | Jimmy Carr

Quick Overview

Jimmy Carr ultimately judges that Mason, one of the twins, is the asshole for repeatedly causing trouble, such as dancing on a table at a club, which led to both twins being kicked out, even though Mason claimed he was the victim.

Key Points: The segment revolves around whether Mason, one of the identical twins, is the asshole for causing an incident at a London nightclub. Mason admitted to dancing on a table at the club, which led to both him and his brother being kicked out after the club staff warned them. The brother, who was wearing a denim jacket, was apparently kicked out for the first time but decided to do it again, leading to the final expulsion. The panelists (including Jimmy Carr, Mo Gilligan, and Sophie Willan) discuss whether Mason or both twins are at fault. The female panelist suggests Mason is the asshole because he caused the situation, although she admits she would do the same thing to save herself. Jimmy Carr ultimately decides that Mason is the asshole, calling the situation a 'close call' but siding against him. The twin who was judged not to be the asshole (not Mason) was described as more conservative than his brother.

Context: This clip is from the panel show "Jimmy Carr's Am I The Ahole?", where host Jimmy Carr presents ethically dubious situations to a panel of comedians and guests who must vote on who is the asshole. The specific scenario involves identical twins where one twin (Mason) engaged in disruptive behavior at a London nightclub, leading to both being ejected, prompting a debate on accountability.

Detailed Analysis

The segment begins with a panelist, later identified as one of the twins, setting up a situation involving himself and his twin brother at a high-end nightclub in London that requires a table fee. He explained that he invited his brother for the first time, and he was living his best life, deciding to jump on a table. He was told by bouncers to get off the table, which he did, but then decided to do it again, resulting in both of them being kicked out. The judge panel, consisting of Jimmy Carr, Mo Gilligan, and Sophie Willan, debates who is the asshole. The twin who did not cause the initial incident stated that his brother is more conservative than him. Sophie Willan argued that Mason (the instigator) is the asshole, but admitted she would do the same thing to save herself. Mo Gilligan initially suggested that since they look alike, they should just give the verdict to both, but then pointed out that the brother was kicked out the first time but then did it again. Jimmy Carr ultimately ruled that Mason is the asshole, calling it a 'close call,' stating that only Mason is the asshole, not the brother, concluding the segment with applause and the twins exiting the stage.