# Aaron Bastani Schools Matt Goodwin On Israel’s Terrorism Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Qyk_cE9nPM Recap page: https://rapidrecap.app/video/9Qyk_cE9nPM Generated: 2025-08-02T14:33:01.238+00:00 --- ## Quick Overview Aaron Bastani directly refutes Matt Goodwin's claims about Israel's actions, drawing parallels between British policy in Palestine in the 1930s and modern Israeli policies, arguing that both have historically used violence and ethnic cleansing to achieve political aims, and that current British policy on recognizing Palestine risks rewarding terrorism. **Key Points:** - Aaron Bastani argues that British policy in 1930s Palestine and modern Israeli policies share similarities in using violence and ethnic cleansing for political ends. - Bastani criticizes the UK's potential recognition of Palestine as a reward for terrorism. - He draws parallels between the creation of Israel and groups using violence, suggesting this incentivizes such tactics. - Bastani cites historical events like the Peel Commission and the actions of paramilitary groups as examples of this pattern. - He asserts that current British foreign policy risks repeating past mistakes by potentially rewarding groups that use violence. - Bastani claims that historical instances of British actions in Palestine, such as suppressing revolts, were also driven by political interests that mirrored current policies. ![Screenshot at 00:14: Matt Goodwin speaking on a news program, with a chyron that reads "PM 'REWARDING HAMAS'? Netanyahu: UK is 'appeasing terrorists' over plans to recognise Palestine."](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-00-14.png) **Context:** This video segment features Aaron Bastani, founder of Novara Media, in a discussion with Matt Goodwin, likely a political commentator or academic, about international relations and historical precedents. The conversation centers on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and criticizes contemporary British foreign policy in relation to the region. Bastani draws historical parallels to the British Mandate period in Palestine and the actions of various groups involved in the conflict. ## Detailed Analysis Aaron Bastani challenges Matt Goodwin's assertions regarding Israel's approach to terrorism and statehood, drawing a stark historical parallel between British actions in Palestine during the 1930s and contemporary Israeli policies. Bastani contends that both have employed violence and ethnic cleansing to advance political objectives. He specifically criticizes the British government's consideration of recognizing Palestine, viewing it as a potential reward for terrorism. Bastani argues that historical precedents, such as the British suppression of Arab revolts and the subsequent establishment of Israel, demonstrate a pattern where violence by one group has been met with concessions or statehood for another. He cites the Peel Commission's partition plan of 1937 as an example of a response to Arab violence that ultimately failed to achieve peace. Bastani also draws a direct analogy to the actions of the Irgun and Lehi paramilitary groups, which engaged in terrorism against British forces and Arab civilians, and argues that the creation of Israel was, in effect, a reward for their violent campaign. He concludes that current British foreign policy, by potentially recognizing a Palestinian state, risks repeating historical mistakes and emboldening groups that resort to violence. ### Historical Parallels - British policy in 1930s Palestine vs. modern Israeli policies - Violence and ethnic cleansing as tools for political gain - Recognition of Palestine as a reward for terrorism ### Critique of British Policy - Consideration of recognizing Palestine as a reward for terrorism - Historical precedents of appeasement and state creation following violence ### Specific Historical Examples - Peel Commission partition plan (1937) - Actions of Irgun and Lehi paramilitary groups ### Core Argument - Violence by one group leading to concessions or statehood for another - Current British policy risks repeating past mistakes ![Screenshot at 00:01: Aaron Bastani, founder of Novara Media, speaking on camera.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-00-01.png) ![Screenshot at 00:14: Matt Goodwin speaking on camera, with the chyron 'PM 'REWARDING HAMAS'?'](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-00-14.png) ![Screenshot at 01:36: Aaron Bastani speaking, referencing historical events related to Israel.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-01-36.png) ![Screenshot at 01:46: Close-up of Aaron Bastani speaking, emphasizing a point.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-01-46.png) ![Screenshot at 02:06: A wider shot showing Aaron Bastani and other participants in a studio setting.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-02-06.png) ![Screenshot at 02:36: Helena \(NoJusticeMTG\) appearing on screen via video call.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-02-36.png) ![Screenshot at 03:12: Close-up of Helena speaking.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-03-12.png) ![Screenshot at 04:44: Close-up of Aaron Bastani making a gesture while speaking.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-04-44.png) ![Screenshot at 05:54: Aaron Bastani makes a point about Winston Churchill's assassination.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-05-54.png) ![Screenshot at 06:11: Aaron Bastani gestures with his hands while explaining historical events.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/9Qyk_cE9nPM/00-06-11.png)