# Doação, descarte e inclusão socioprodutiva: os desafios do impacto | Liliane Linhares | TEDxUnisinos

Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TPoQ3ZlzYo
Recap page: https://rapidrecap.app/video/4TPoQ3ZlzYo
Generated: 2026-03-02T17:02:54.806+00:00

---
## Quick Overview

Liliane Linhares argues that addressing social issues like exclusion and poverty among women, especially those with disabilities or who are elderly, requires moving beyond traditional charity models toward sustainable, inclusive socio-productive entrepreneurship models that generate real income and value, rather than just distributing discarded goods.

**Key Points:**
- 70% of donations received after major events like the floods in Rio Grande do Sul were clothes, highlighting a misplaced focus on charity over sustainable solutions.
- The speaker advocates for a socioeconomic impact model that focuses on inclusion and sustainable income generation rather than pure donation.
- The traditional model often results in discarding usable items because they do not fit standard consumer needs (e.g., clothing for men, children, or specific sizes), reinforcing exclusion.
- The project developed by the speaker aims to create a 'circular' and 'human' economic model where discarded materials (like clothing) are transformed into new products by marginalized women.
- The speaker emphasizes that this work is not charity but 'business' that creates real economic value and autonomy for women who lack formal employment or social support.
- The goal is to empower women, such as those who care for disabled relatives or children not in school, by giving them opportunities for productive inclusion and self-esteem.

![Screenshot at 00:03: The title slide appears, posing the central question of the talk: 'VERDADE OU CONSEQUÊNCIA?' \(Truth or Consequence?\), setting the stage for a discussion about confronting difficult realities.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/4TPoQ3ZlzYo/00-00-03.jpg)

**Context:** Liliane Linhares presents her TEDxUnisinos talk, titled 'Truth or Consequence?', focusing on the societal challenges faced by marginalized women—including those caring for dependents, lacking formal employment, or being elderly—and argues for a shift from reactive charity to proactive, sustainable socio-productive inclusion through entrepreneurship, using examples of discarded materials being transformed into valuable products.

## Detailed Analysis

Liliane Linhares challenges the audience's perception of social work, contrasting the common approach of reactive charity with a sustainable model of productive inclusion. She highlights a specific issue where, following floods in Rio Grande do Sul, 70% of donations were clothing, much of which was ultimately discarded because it didn't fit standard consumer profiles (e.g., men's clothes, baby clothes). This waste, she argues, is a consequence of a model that focuses on immediate relief rather than long-term empowerment. Linhares champions a new 'circular and human' economic model where discarded materials are transformed by marginalized women—those who are unemployed, elderly, or primary caregivers—into valuable new products. She stresses that this work is not charity but a real business generating income and fostering self-esteem, emphasizing that the state often fails to support these individuals adequately, leaving them dependent on precarious situations. She concludes by inviting the audience to support this inclusive economic model that turns waste into opportunity and value.

### The Problem with Charity

- Maria not going to work because she lacks employment or support
- Women not fitting the traditional work model (no education, no teeth, dependent on social programs)
- 70% of donations after floods were clothing, much of which was discarded.

### The Proposed Solution

- Implementing a socio-productive inclusion model that creates value from waste
- Transforming discarded materials (like clothing) into new products using basic skills like sewing.

### The Philosophy

- This is not charity but real business that creates value and self-esteem
- The model promotes a 'circular and human' economy
- It challenges the idea that the state must sustain everyone.

### Call to Action

- Invite the audience to support the women and the sustainable economic model
- Think about how much waste is discarded that could be transformed into value.

![Screenshot at 00:07: Speaker Liliane Linhares introduced on the TEDx screen, adopting a welcoming gesture.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/4TPoQ3ZlzYo/00-00-07.jpg)
![Screenshot at 00:35: Screen displays an image of women working together, likely involved in the production or preparation of goods, illustrating community involvement.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/4TPoQ3ZlzYo/00-00-35.jpg)
![Screenshot at 00:49: A close-up image shows a hand wearing a ring, possibly symbolizing commitment or personal investment in the work being discussed.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/4TPoQ3ZlzYo/00-00-49.jpg)
![Screenshot at 01:28: A slide shows a pile of discarded shoes, visually representing the 'waste' that the speaker discusses transforming into value.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/4TPoQ3ZlzYo/00-01-28.jpg)
![Screenshot at 02:21: A slide shows a woman wearing glasses and a green shirt, emphasizing the individual faces behind the social challenge.](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/4TPoQ3ZlzYo/00-02-21.jpg)