# The 19 Year Process of Inventing a New Apple

Channel: Half as Interesting
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2XUwzGWEdaM
Recap page: https://rapidrecap.app/video/2XUwzGWEdaM
Generated: 2025-07-10T04:39:58.783+00:00

---
## Quick Overview

Inventing a new apple variety like EverCrisp or Honeycrisp is a 19-year process involving meticulous cross-breeding, grafting, and rigorous selection, costing commercial growers annual fees and per-tree royalties. This shift from open varieties to "club apples" ensures consistent quality and allows breeders to maintain control and profitability through trademarks and managed cooperatives, unlike the open-source Honeycrisp which faced branding challenges after its patent expired.

## Summary

**Key Points:**
- Developing a new apple variety like EverCrisp takes approximately 19 years from cross-breeding to market.
- Commercial growers pay annual fees ($100/year) and per-tree royalties ($1 initial, then $0.20-$0.30/tree annually) to grow club apples.
- Apple breeding involves hand-pollinating specific trees, growing thousands of seedlings, and grafting the best onto rootstock over multiple generations to select for desired traits and eliminate flaws.
- The Honeycrisp apple, released in 1991, earned the University of Minnesota over $6 million in royalties from its patent before it expired in 2008.
- The expiration of Honeycrisp's patent led to inconsistent quality in the market, prompting the development of "club apples" which use perpetual trademarks and managed cooperatives to control quality and revenue.
- Club apples like EverCrisp, SnapDragon, RubyFrost, and Ludacrisp are managed through exclusive grower cooperatives that enforce strict standards for cultivation and marketing.
- Honeycrisp trees are finicky, requiring hand-thinning, being susceptible to disease and heat, and having fragile wood and thin-skinned apples that damage easily during picking.

**Context:** The video explores the complex and costly process of developing new apple varieties, particularly focusing on the shift from traditional "open varieties" to modern "club apples." This change was driven by the success and subsequent challenges of the Honeycrisp apple, which highlighted the need for greater control over quality and branding in the apple industry. The process involves extensive scientific breeding and agricultural management, often spanning decades.

## Detailed Analysis

The video explains that growing "club apples" like EverCrisp involves significant costs for commercial growers, including a $100 annual fee, a $1 per tree initial fee, and additional per-tree royalties of $0.20 (years 4-10) and $0.30 (year 10+). These apples are managed by associations like MAIA, controlling their growth, picking, packaging, and sales. Unlike typical grocery store apples, club apples are more akin to branded products like iPhones due to their controlled development and marketing. The EverCrisp apple took 19 years from cross-breeding to market. The process of creating a new apple variety involves hand-pollinating flowers from two desirable trees, collecting seeds, planting them in a nursery, and then grafting the seedlings onto rootstock. Thousands of trees are grown, and only the best are propagated, with the rest terminated, a process repeated over several generations to eliminate flaws. The Honeycrisp apple, released in 1991 and gaining popularity by 2007, was a result of this lengthy breeding process, specifically from a cross-breed in Minnesota in 1960 (MN-1711) that was nearly discarded but saved by horticulturist David Bedford. Honeycrisp's unique large cells burst when bitten, providing its signature crispness. The University of Minnesota patented Honeycrisp, earning over $6 million in royalties before the patent expired in 2008. The expiration of the patent led to quality control issues as anyone could grow and sell Honeycrisps, regardless of quality. This problem led to the rise of "club apples," which use trademarks (which don't expire) and managed grower cooperatives to ensure consistent quality and continued revenue for breeders. Growers pay fees to these cooperatives for the right to grow and sell the branded apple, ensuring quality standards are met. Examples of successful club apples include EverCrisp, SnapDragon, RubyFrost, and Ludacrisp, each with distinct flavors and managed distribution.

### Cost of Growing Club Apples

- $100/year annual fee
- $1/tree initial fee
- $0.20/tree (years 4-10)
- $0.30/tree (year 10+)
- Only commercial growers can plant them

### EverCrisp and Club Apples

- EverCrisp is a "club apple"
- Growing, picking, packaging, and sales are meticulously managed by MAIA (Midwest Apple Improvement Association)
- Club apples are branded products, similar to iPhones, with controlled development and marketing

### The Apple Breeding Process

- Apples grow on grafted trees, not from seeds, to ensure genetic consistency
- Hand-pollinate flowers of two good trees
- Collect seeds and plant in a nursery
- Graft seedlings onto rootstock to grow trees
- Select best trees for propagation, eliminating others
- Repeat process over multiple generations to weed out flaws (disease, sunburn, poor storage)
- Takes decades to develop a commercially viable apple variety (e.g., Honeycrisp took 19 years)

### Honeycrisp's Origin and Impact

- Resulted from a 1960 cross-breed (MN-1711) in Minnesota
- Nearly terminated but saved by horticulturist David Bedford
- Released in 1991, gained popularity in 2007
- Unique large cells burst when bitten, creating crispness
- University of Minnesota patented Honeycrisp, earning over $6 million in royalties before patent expired in 2008
- Open variety status led to inconsistent quality and branding issues after patent expiration

### The Rise of Club Apples

- Developed to address branding and quality control issues of open varieties like Honeycrisp
- Patents expire, but trademarks do not, allowing perpetual control
- Breeders charge royalties for buying trees and for selling apples under the trademarked name
- Growers must join cooperatives that enforce quality standards and marketing efforts
- Examples include EverCrisp, SnapDragon, RubyFrost, and Ludacrisp

### Characteristics of Club Apples

- EverCrisp: perfect Honeycrisp-like taste
- SnapDragon: tangy, provides strength
- RubyFrost: tougher, good and good-looking
- Ludacrisp: tastes like pineapple
- All require significant investment and careful management due to specific growing challenges (e.g., Honeycrisp's fragile wood, heat sensitivity, thin skin, pointy stems)

![Screenshot at 00:18: Farmer with apples and price tags](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-00-18.png)
![Screenshot at 00:24: EverCrisp apple with trademark](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-00-24.png)
![Screenshot at 00:45: EverCrisp and iPhone website comparison](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-00-45.png)
![Screenshot at 00:57: Honeycrisp apple with "19 Years" text](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-00-57.png)
![Screenshot at 01:22: Cornell University's apple breeding program website](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-01-22.png)
![Screenshot at 02:00: Animated apple tree grafting process](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-02-00.png)
![Screenshot at 03:45: US Patent for Honeycrisp apple](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-03-45.png)
![Screenshot at 04:29: Patented apple on money stacks](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-04-29.png)
![Screenshot at 05:04: Patent vs. Registered Trademark comparison](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-05-04.png)
![Screenshot at 06:17: Four club apple varieties on a table](https://ss.rapidrecap.app/screens/2XUwzGWEdaM/00-06-17.png)